And if the franchise players of the past are any indication, a star’s first quest for the Stanley Cup may not translate to immediate success, but it could lay the foundation for multiple titles down the road.
One year removed from his first NHL season, legendary Boston Bruins defenceman Bobby Orr helped his team out of the bottom of the Wales Conference to return to the playoffs against the Montreal Canadiens in the conference quarter-finals.
It didn’t take long for the future perennial Norris Trophy winner to rebound, though, as he went on to help the Bruins capture the Stanley Cup twice in the next four seasons. Some may recall that now iconic championship-winning goal from Game 4 of the 1970 final against the St. Louis Blues.
In his first season in the NHL, a 19-year-old Wayne Gretzky got his first run at the Cup with the 16th-place Edmonton Oilers. The team didn’t exactly stack up against the first-place Philadelphia Flyers and the Oilers were swept 3-0.
But Gretzky continued the momentum from his 137-point regular season by scoring two goals and adding an assist in the series. Four years later, he went on to lead Edmonton to its first championship in 1984, followed by three more in the next four seasons.
Mario Lemieux took a longer path to his playoff debut, reaching the post-season five years after he was drafted by the Pittsburgh Penguins in 1984. But he had the greatest initial impact, helping his second-place team to the Patrick Division semifinal against the fourth-place Flyers.
It was Game 5 against Philadelphia where Lemieux established his greatness. The 23-year-old powered Pittsburgh to a 10-7 victory by scoring a record-setting three goals in the first 6:55, tying the record for most goals in a period with his fourth later in the first and matched the record for most goals in a playoff game with an empty-net goal for his fifth.
He finished with eight points, tying the single-game playoff record. Lemieux won back-to-back championships the two following seasons.
Eric Lindros is the only one on the list who never hoisted the Cup, but he had a strong playoff debut for the Flyers, tallying four goals and 11 assists in 12 games.
His second-place Flyers couldn’t handle the eventual champion New Jersey Devils, falling 4-2 in the Eastern final. However, Lindros helped Philadelphia claw back into the series with the game-winning goal in overtime of Game 3.
Crosby only needed two more years to bring the Cup back to Pittsburgh in 2009. He then earned MVP honours en route to claiming his second championship last season.